Take a tour
invite your friends
- Select Menu -
Invite your friends
I am officially overweight according to dr. koop
former surgeon general. Please visit this calculator and tell me they are crazy? TIA
Tue. Sep 27, 5:59am
where's the calculator?
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 6:33 AM
2nd try for the link...
Here we go.
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 6:58 AM
I'm overweight too! I'm 5'1" and 127lbs, and it said for me to get into the "normal" range, I need to drop at least 14lbs! It didn't ask for any measurements besides how much overlap you get when you put your hand around your wrist - didn't ask if I have wide hips - I do, or big boobs - I'm a D-cup! My stomach is flat! Maybe I could lose 5lbs from my hips/thighs, but if I lost much more than that, I'd look sick!
This Dr. is sick!
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 8:02 AM
It said I was overweight, too - and I am.
I am 5'2" and 133 lbs. It said I was "marginally overweight" and that my ideal weight range is 118-129.8. I agree with that.
What kind of results did you get?
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 8:29 AM
I'm overweight too.
I'm overweight too according to the calculator. But I know it is true. I've got 21lbs to lose, and I kinda knew that I was in that range (to say the least). *sigh* But that is why I'm here, and frankly I'm glad I'm working on it instead of still sitting around eating cheese and pate with glass after glass of wine.
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 8:37 AM
It told me I was at the low end of my ideal body weight (154 for 5'8", medium frame.) It said my ideal range is 154-164 lbs. I know this wasn't what you intended when you started this thread but I just have to say thanks because I've been feeling a little down and this made me feel better this morning!
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 9:10 AM
It told me I am at my ideal weight. I am 5' 8" and weigh about 145 lbs.
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 9:26 AM
okay - well all these results sound TOTALLY random!! This may be a problem with the website's calculator rather than Dr. Koop himself - or maybe not. I don't know.
Who cares. Deep down - everyone knows if they're overweight or not. If you really have to ask, you probably aren't. Or, you're so close, you only need to make minor adjustments.
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 9:46 AM
totally random indeed
b/c i am also 5.8 and weigh 155. dr. koop said that was ideal. but he also said the same thing for the poster above. it's dumb. you can't determine you're body type by how your fingers wrap around your wrist.
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 9:53 AM
Actually, I kind of disagree with that; your frame (bone size, which you can tell by wrapping your fingers around your wrist) has a lot to do with your body type. My ideal weight is 145, and I know I would look pretty thin at that weight, but I have a big frame, big bones. I have friends who are the same height but have smaller bone structure and they wear a couple of sizes smaller than I do but we look almost the same size.
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 10:05 AM
Okay, I am 5'1", 126lbs, and when I wrap my fingers around my wrist, my thumb and middle finger overlap by maybe a centimeter. I wear a D-cup bra and usually a "medium" top (t-shirt, etc.) but wear about a size 10 buttondown shirt, b/c anything smaller will pull apart at the boobs, though a much smaller size would fit the rest of me. I wear about a size 6 pants - womens fit better than juniors because I'm curvy. I have quite a bit of muscle - when I flex my arms, a "bubble" of muscle pops up on my bicep, not just that long lean extra muscle that most women have. My back is also extremely muscular, as are my legs.
What is my body type? My bones are probably pretty small, but I have a lot of muscle weight!
Tuesday, September 27, 2005, 12:13 PM
well how much do u weigh? have u calculated your bmi before? i think it seems ok to me did u check for mistakes in your weight or height?
Sunday, October 02, 2005, 9:11 PM
~150lbs. - 5'6" - medium frame - active
dr. koop says:
"Ideal weight is 142 - 156.2 lbs. Congratulations! Your weight is ideal! "
personally, i would like to be 140-145, but was down to 133 last summer/fall!
i had a lot going on though - don't know if that was a good, healthy weight for me at the time:( dr. koop says that weight at my height is "underweight", but damn, i was smokin'!
Sunday, October 02, 2005, 9:41 PM
dr. koop is crazy
supposedly I need to drop 6 pounds off of my 112. I may personally think that but I dont think any doctor would find in necessary. anyways musle ways more than fat. Everyone needs to go to ediets.com and get a free profile because they'll give you a much more realistic answer:)
Sunday, October 02, 2005, 10:28 PM
and how are you sure if you are in the middle of a small or med. frame?
the ideal weight for small frame's high end is a pound away from the med frame's low end... weird
Monday, October 03, 2005, 10:10 AM
I'm fat too according to him. And I'm thin accoriding to other places. when will I stop looking at these??
Tuesday, October 04, 2005, 8:01 AM
These calculators are too generalized.
If you are muscular, you are going to weigh more. A professional, thin-as-a-rail ballet dancer or skater would be carrying a significant amount of weight in muscle.
Also, people distribute fat differently on their body. Some people it is really noticeable when they are 10 lbs overweight, other people not.
I think measurements, while a pain, are a more accurate gauge.
Tuesday, October 04, 2005, 9:45 AM
I went to the dr. koop site again. I'm still overweight and I've lost 7 pounds. I don't know why this is bothering me!
Wednesday, January 18, 2006, 3:05 PM
I posted before - the 4th post down - and at 5'1", with a small frame, it told me that the upper end of ideal is 112 lbs!
When I originally posted, I was 127 lbs. Now I am 121. At 127, I thought 5lbs was the most I could lose. Now, 6lbs down, I look good, but I could see losing another 3-5 lbs or so. I'm certainly healthy; this is just for vanity. But even then, I wouldn't be what Dr. Koop calls "healthy." Honestly, I just wouldn't worry about this Dr. Koop!
Wednesday, January 18, 2006, 3:22 PM
Well, I always thought I was more medium frame, but just barely medium frame. However, my thumb and major finger barely overlap, so I could be 7 pounds overweight. I don't always trust these sorts of websites. They cannot actually see us. I would say one's own doctor would be more of an expert.
Wednesday, January 18, 2006, 3:34 PM
I'm Ideal ? No Way !
well I spotted myself a 1/4" and said I was 5' 9", 175 lbs. Dr. Koop said "Congratulations! Your weight is ideal! " However, every other site I've looked at plus the evidence of my own eyes, says I'm overweight - by at least 20 lbs.
The suggested wieghts vary a lot by frame size - for my height:
150 - 165 lbs. (68 - 75 kg.) for a small frame
160 - 176 lbs. (73 - 80 kg). for a medium frame
170 - 187 lbs. (77 - 85 kg.) for a large frame.
but the descriptions of frame size are incredibly vague. No one who's ever seen me would say I'm small framed, yet by this site I'm on the edge between small and medium. And I know I have disproportionately small hands (it's a fun party trick) and disproportionately broad shoulders - so how should I adjust for that?
Bottom line: don't sweat it. Go with what your eyes and your doctor tell you. I like the idea of adjusting ideal weight by frame size, but Dr. Koop needs to come up with a much more precise defininition before I trust his numbers.
Wednesday, January 18, 2006, 3:57 PM
It said it was based on BMI.
And we ALL know how inaccurate the BMI can be. This calculator attempts to take frame into size but any woman can tell you that her frame is not just limited to her bone size.
That being said, it told me I was marginally overweight and I am so it worked okay for me.
Wednesday, January 18, 2006, 4:10 PM
I don't believe in any of it. I gage my ideal weight based on my energy level.
Thursday, January 19, 2006, 10:17 AM
It makes no sense. It's telling me I am UNDERweight (I am about 118 and 5'5"). I certainly do not look underweight at all - I thought I was at a good weight for my height and frame (which is small according to their little test, but I still think I have more of a medium frame).
Tuesday, March 21, 2006, 4:54 PM
Yep, I think there are much better sites for this.
I am 5'7" and weigh 145 lbs. and it says that I am underweight !
Wednesday, March 22, 2006, 6:58 AM
I am unaware of know who Dr. Koop is, but I know in the medical field they have a rule of thumb so to speak. I have consulted on many cases and what is said for women is at 5 feet tall you should be about 105 and for every additional inch 5 pounds should be added. This does somewhat take into consideration frame as the known world of skeletal structure would be in a range of about 5 - 10 pounds from this. This is a weight you are most likely to be medically healthy at.
Wednesday, March 22, 2006, 10:26 AM
I am unaware or know who Dr. Koop is **
Wednesday, March 22, 2006, 10:42 AM
Oh well I am 7 pounds over weight for my height guess I would not be here if I was underweight LOL
Wednesday, March 22, 2006, 8:26 PM
I always go by BMI
Wednesday, March 22, 2006, 8:28 PM
Dr Koop was the Surgeon General in the Reagan administration.
I did his calculation and it said I was overweight. I am 5'2/158 lbs. I do 30 min of cardio 4 times a week with spirts beyond 85% of my target heart rate. I have been weight training for years, including bench pressing more than half my body weight, quite muscular but also fluctuating body fat, thanks to genetics and hormones. His calculation is too rigid. It does not take muscle weight into consideration. After years of training and frustration with conventional measurements, I have given up on the numbers. I look at the numbers of cholesterol, blood pressure, etc for confirmation I'm doing well.
Wednesday, April 05, 2006, 8:32 AM
I started my day off thinking I was doing great and now I feel bad about myself. I wonder how accurate this is.
Thursday, January 11, 2007, 9:47 AM
Beware what they're using to determine body frame. My fingers overlap when encircling my wrist. Am I small framed? By no stretch of the imagination. I have long fingers! Don't let one calulator get you down. There are countless versions on the internet. Some getting praise one day and debunked the next. Best is to discuss this with a physician you trust.
Thursday, January 11, 2007, 10:37 AM
Well I have to disagree. It says I'm underweight. I'm 5'8 144 and would like to get to 135. According to BMI this is still a healthy weight for my height but according to this calculator I need to gain 10lbs!!!
It says I should be between 154 and 169.4 but when I calculate my BMI I need to be at least 164 to have a healthy BMI so at least for me this is way high... not low.
Thursday, January 11, 2007, 10:58 AM
dr. koop is full of poop. why, after so many posted with comments about how inaccurrate the calcultor is, did people continue to use it, only to echo the same results? silly. it's nice to be able to see on paper that we are healthy, but we've really got to be vigilant when it comes to deciding which information to believe!!
Thursday, January 11, 2007, 11:31 AM
I'm the 9/27/2005, 8:02AM poster, and the 1/18/2006, 3:22pm poster, and a year later, I've lost another 3lbs, so now I'm only 6lbs above "ideal" by Dr. Koop. Now, I definitely think I'm healthy, but, when I was 15 lbs above his "ideal" range, I thought I couldn't possibly lose more than 5lbs without being too thin. Now that I've lost 9lbs, I think I could definitely use to lose 6lbs more.
Although I disagree with Dr. Koop on his measurement of "ideal," it does make me wonder if we look at ourselves and either over- or underestimate how much we need to lose/gain, because we really don't know what we will look like at different specific weights, or how healthy we will feel. Just a thought!
Thursday, January 11, 2007, 3:07 PM
Ideal weight range is 138 - 151.8 lbs..
You are marginally overweight by 4.2 lbs.
I can believe that. I think these tests are just a guide. You know what you need to do! Good luck in reaching all of your goals!
Thursday, January 11, 2007, 4:17 PM
I checked it out and it said that my weight is on track when my BMI says im overweight hmm go figure
Friday, January 12, 2007, 1:04 AM
I LOVE that calculator
It says that I am UNDERWEIGHT at 5'4 128. Made me kinda feel good...especially since I have another 10lbs to lose!
Friday, January 12, 2007, 11:00 AM
It seems realistic!
That calculator is the only place that's given me a "realistic" goal weight (i.e. where I naturally fell for most of my life)... and it's 145, so we're not talking like majorly big. I kind of like it, even though my goal is less than 145.. .that seems attainable since I've been there before.
Friday, January 12, 2007, 11:03 AM
HAHA !! I am not over weight right....well if I gain 1 pound I be LOL
Saturday, January 13, 2007, 7:47 PM
Hmmm...it told me I was underweight. At 5'9 and 155 pounds I doubt that.
Saturday, January 13, 2007, 10:35 PM
I always thought I was average but apparently not. I am a 16yr old 5,4 112ib girl and its verdicy was underweight. It says I should weigh between 126 and 136ibs. I geuss its good if its true because I want to be a Horse Jockey, I am at the moment trying to get down to 98ibs so I will be small enough to ride. To be honest I thought I was fat lol. What does anyone else think?
Wednesday, February 07, 2007, 10:22 AM
oh and I am small framed? make sense?
Wednesday, February 07, 2007, 10:24 AM
To the 16-year-old, don't take this the wrong way, but Dr. Koop's calculator applies best to full-grown women. While you may be done growing taller, you likely haven't completely finished going through puberty and filling out. 5'4" and 112lbs is very thin for an adult, but though it's thin for anyone, it's probably not "too thin" for a 16-year-old. But, before you try and get down to 98lbs, even if being a jockey is your goal, you should discuss that with your doctor. It may not be healthy for you to lose that much weight. Depending on your body composition, you could become so skinny that you stop menstruating or stunt any potential future growth. When your body stops doing what it's supposed to be doing (i.e. menstruating or growing), it's telling you that something is wrong, and it can't function properly. At 5'4", you may just be too tall to healthily weigh little enough to be a jockey. I'm 5'1", and I'm taller than most jockeys!
Wednesday, February 07, 2007, 10:35 AM
ya i'm a big girl........who am i kiding i'm a HUGE GIRL! i have to use a wheel chair to get around and i'm 13! i'm morbidly obese at 4' 9" i weight almost 400lbs (392 to be exact) i can't fit in desks at school so they ordered a desk for "my size" ppl i want to be thin but i don't want to stop eating i eat durein class i eat three lunches a day at school for dinner i eat 4 double cheese burgers 2 large fries and 3 blizzards..........i luv to eat it's my live and i like it my friends say i'm fat and my parents always say no more burgers u had four already and i say i don't care I WANT MORE then i start screaming and they ALWAYS give me as MUCH AS I WANT i luv them!! so ya i'm fat and i no i'll never have SEX EVER but that's ok cuz i luv to eat and i no i'm healthy in my own way
Sunday, August 26, 2007, 8:07 PM
I'm 5'3, 107 and it says I'm underweight by 7 pounds, so I think it's pretty accurate.
Sunday, August 26, 2007, 9:00 PM
At 5'4", small framed, and 120lbs, it says I'm at my ideal weight, which I guess seems fine. It doesn't take into account fat vs. muscle though, so someone with a lot of 'flab' may weigh the same as someone with more muscle, but will appear bigger. (For the record I have some muscle and a little bit of flab too, but maybe they cancel eachother out, lol).
Wednesday, August 29, 2007, 11:22 AM
Wednesday, August 29, 2007, 11:43 AM
I have a medium size frame, i'm 5'11 and 184. It says i am fine and my range is 172 to 189. But my BMI limit is 175 i beleive. Who is this Dr. Koop?
Wednesday, August 29, 2007, 11:50 AM
I'm 5'8, 125 pounds of mostly lean weight, and the calculator says my 'Ideal weight range is 144 - 158.4 lbs. (65.5 - 72 kg.). You are underweight. '. Oh, forget it. I feel to heavy for myself at 130, and he's suggesting me to gain another 33 pounds? That's crap. Also, my BMI is at a healthy 20.
Wednesday, August 29, 2007, 12:08 PM
I supposedly have a small frame, but I am leaning towards medium due to the simple fact that my fingers are extremely long. I'm 6'0", 185 lbs, I am on the slender side, what you would call a "Pirate's dream" with the "Sunken chest"... Okay... okay, they're not THAT small, but could use to be bigger... anyways, If I go by what the small frame says, I am on the verge of being overweight. If by the medium frame, I am right in the middle. Every body is different, and so these things cannot be completely/nearly accurate. I chose to use my own opinion in this instance. I am not even going to go by my dr's opinion. According to her, I'm anorexic while other BMI's online tell me I'm obese... go figure!
Tuesday, November 13, 2007, 9:55 AM
Your ideal weight range-- 138 - 151.8 lbs. (62.7 - 69 kg.). --is based on a formula that calculates what a healthy weight is for most people of your height (67 inches) and frame size (Small).
Congratulations, your weight is ideal!
...wonderful! (I'm 149 lbs. btw, and would still like to get down to 140 lbs.)
Tuesday, November 13, 2007, 10:19 AM
I did that as well and it says I'm overweight by A LOT! I know I am overweight some, but it was saying my ideal weight was 106-116lbs. I would be WAY too skinny!!!!
Tuesday, November 13, 2007, 10:31 AM
The Problem Is BMI
The calculator isn't broken -- it's just not particularly accurate.
The issue is the formula that it's using -- which is Body Mass Index. BMI is notoriously inaccurate for people who have a high-proportion of muscle on their frames. It will typically overstate your "fatness" because the calculation is based only on height and weight, and not lean body mass. It will also be fairly inaccurate for the elderly also, because they tend to have lean tissue than the average adult. So in the case of older people, it may actually under-estimate body fat.
I do have to at least give them credit for asking a "build" question about your frame size, which at least adjusts a bit for body type. My numbers were off as well, still, but that's because I'm between 10-12 percent body fat most of the time, and the standard BMI calculation is based on a sedentary adult with "average" lean body mass. That's probably not be, or many of the people on this site that weight train regularly.
This calc really underscores why scale weight is a terrible indicator of body composition. You are almost always better using something like calipers to get accurate body comps.
For anyone interested, here is everything you could possibly want to know about the body mass index, including why it's not a great gauge of overall health and fitness:
Best of luck and don't sweat Dr. Koop. ;-)
Saturday, January 10, 2009, 3:23 PM
Is Dr. Koop overweight? The man who founded curves isn't skinny. Also, I used to work for a weight loss clinic. They guy who owned it? Fat.
Kick in the butt, isn't it?
Sunday, January 11, 2009, 1:19 AM
It said i was underweight so maybe yall r just fat..... N im 5 11 n weigh 125
Thursday, January 15, 2009, 10:39 AM
no u r underweight there smarta$$
Thursday, January 15, 2009, 11:02 AM
5'5" 159 medium frame
it said I was a little overweight, but that I only need to lose ~9 lbs.
I know I need to lose more than that to be healthy and in my ideal weight range according to LA Fitness when I joined and my past experience with weight. I used to weigh 135 and I was still a little chunky!
Thursday, January 15, 2009, 3:55 PM
r u really actually 13 and that chunky ??
Friday, March 27, 2009, 9:29 PM
Ideal weight range is 124 - 136.4 lbs. (56.4 - 62 kg.). Contratulations! Your weight is ideal!
I did not expect this at all actually. I am 19 years old and in my own opinion, I could lose maybe another 7 pounds or so. My doctor says I am normal weight, other BMI calculators say I am overweight, and this one seems to say I am at my ideal weight. But whats different is that when I went to my doctors, I weighed 6 pounds more. So this is making everything real difficult to understand.
Friday, March 12, 2010, 6:37 AM
At this thread began over 3 years ago my guess would be that the calculator was re-calibrated based on new findings. This site is super slow though and there are many more reliable, less slow sites out there that I prefer to use.
Friday, March 12, 2010, 9:17 AM
How To Lose Weight- The Basics
Weight Watchers Points System
The Fat Smash Diet
The Eat To Live Diet
The Beck Diet Solution
How To Get The Motivation To Lose Weight
How To Be Successful Using PEERtrainer
How To Burn Fat
Online Weight Loss Support- How It Works
Does Green Tea Help You Lose Weight?
Tips On Using PEERtrainer
Visit The PEERtrainer Community
Diet and Fitness Resources
Weight Watchers Meetings
Learning To Inspire Others: You Already Are
Writing Down Your Daily Workouts
Spending Money On A Personal Trainer?
How I Became A Marathon Runner
How To Prevent Injuries During Your Workout
Flu Season: Should You Take The Flu Shot?
Are You Really Ready To Start PEERtrainer?
Super Foods That Can Boost Your Energy
Reversing Disease Through Nutrition
New Diet and Fitness Articles:
Weight Watchers Points Plus
How To Adjust Your Body To Exercise
New: Weight Watchers Momentum Program
New: PEERtrainer Blog Archive
Review Of The New Weight Watchers Momentum Program
Weight Loss Motivation by Joshua Wayne:
Why Simple Goal Setting Is Not Enough
How To Delay Short Term Gratification
How To Stay Motivated
How To Exercise With A Busy Schedule
Real World Nutrition and Fitness Questions
Can Weight Lifting Help You Lose Weight?
Are Protein Drinks Safe?
Nutrition As Medicine?
Everyday Weight Loss Tips
How To Eat Healthy At A Party
How To Eat Out And Still Lose Weight
The Three Bite Rule
Tips On How To Stop A Binge
Introducing The PEERtrainer Cheat System
How To Speed Up Weight Loss
How To Get Motivation To Lose Weight
Weight Watchers: The New Science!
3 Myths About Weight Loss With JJ Virgin
Related Article :
New PEERtrainer Articles :
Why Green Tea Helps You Lose Weight
How To Lose A Lot Of Weight, Fast
5 Things You Must Know Before Doing A Cleanse
New: How To Build Muscle
What Is The Best Kind Of Protein Powder?
The Master Cleanse
Will Removing Gluten From Your Diet Help You Lose Weight?
How To Obliterate Your Limitations
How To Get The Motivation To Exercise
How To Stop Feeling Tired
Dr. Joel Fuhrman's Super Immunity Diet
The PEERtrainer Diet
Is Portion Control Keeping You Fat?
The Ultimate Guide To Dietary Fiber
P90X? Do Burst Training Instead
Weight Watchers Points Changes For 2012
Can Diet Soda Cause You To GAIN Weight?