CommunityBrowse groupsBlogEtiquetteInvite Your friendsSuccess Stories

Lounge
Community 


elliptical vs. treadmill or rower?

Which one is best? Does anyone have a circut training that they would recommend with all three?

Thu. Nov 30, 9:31am

Add comment  
You get a full-body workout on the erg (legs, abs, arms and shoulders) that you won't get on a treadmill or elliptical.

Thursday, November 30, 2006, 9:41 AM

Add comment
ITA. the rower is excellent for upper body cardiovascular. I would do interval training, one day elliptical, one day treadmill, and so on.

Thursday, November 30, 2006, 4:25 PM

Add comment
Mixing up your cardio will be best in the long run. Try to do all 3 each week.

Thursday, November 30, 2006, 5:04 PM

Add comment
my knees (and boobs, actually) can't handle running on the treadmill, so I stick to the elliptical
another good one is the arc trainer (if that's what it's called) - it's like a cross between an elliptical and a stair master

Thursday, November 30, 2006, 9:38 PM

Add comment
re boobs : put on appropriate sport bra or you will hurt your back

Saturday, December 02, 2006, 2:20 AM

Add comment
my trainer has me do 10 min of each: running or elliptical, then rowing, then biking....each as fast as you can...what a workout!

Sunday, December 03, 2006, 6:16 PM

Add comment
Running for large-chested women

I wear a Goddess bra that is slightly too small plus an Enell bra and, together, that does the trick to allow me to run.

Sunday, December 03, 2006, 7:51 PM

Add comment
I sell fitness equipment and am vehemently opposed to ellipticals.

You don't have to run on a treadmill to use it!!! Nor do you need to run to get a great workout. Set the incline to 12% or higher and a 4 mile an hour pace. Less impact than walking through a mall but it's an intense workout- better than an elliptical.

Ellipticals rarely ever have one's body in proper alignment. Moreover, while there is no impact on the knee, a) there is constant pressure on the knee b) many ellipticals result in users pronating their knees while on them which causes knee problems. Also, leaning forward with shoulders and hips out of allignment can cause lower back pain, and really is NOT how one should be positioned when working out. Thinking you get a better workout cuz you use your arms is kind of silly seeing as the elliptical arms are moving even if you're not holding onto them- better to be moving your arms in a natural motion against gravity on a treadmill.

The only good thing I can say about an elliptical is it's better than sitting on a couch, but that's about it.

Sunday, December 03, 2006, 9:01 PM

Add comment
to above poster, no matter what i do on a treadmill i am in bad pain, running or walking, whatever the incline it hurts. sometimes it hurts my knees, sometimes my shins, sometimes my boobs, often all three, along with the fact that i get out of breath on treadmills where i don't on an ellyptical meaning i can never do the treadmill for more than 6 min at a time. i like the ellyptical, it makes me feel like i've exercized (sweating, muscle use etc.) but doesn't leave me in pain.
i like rowers too, but i have bad elbows and knees which means i can't do it for to long.

Tuesday, December 05, 2006, 6:47 PM

Add comment
Can anyone tell me if there's a difference in noise and vibration of the eliptical versus the treadmill or a stationary bicycle? My dh is hesitant to get a treadmill - he likes to run but feels having a treadmill at home will cause too much vibration in the house.

The other thing that was making me think we should look into an elliptical or stationary bike is that both of our primary cardio workout of choice is to walk/run outside, and this would give some variety to our training.

Thanks for any advice!

Friday, December 08, 2006, 2:29 PM

Add comment
I can't afford to join a gym or buy a lot of equipment, so if I can only buy ONE of the above for home exercise -- either a treadmill or a rower (I don't like ellipticals myself), which one would be the best? I also supplement my cardio with low-impact video workouts, like The Firm. From the above, it sounds like a rower would be a better bet, but I have never used one. My knees aren't great but I can jog at a moderate pace (5.7 mph) for 30 minutes on a treadmill. I won't even try to run outside on pavement. What is the general consensus -- treadmill or rower?

Wednesday, December 03, 2008, 11:20 AM

Add comment
Regarding home equipment - it's which ever piece of equipment you will actually USE!! And not to drape clothes on :)

p.s. I wouldn't buy any equipment I've tried it and have determined this is something I love and will use often.

Wednesday, December 03, 2008, 12:58 PM

Add comment
ere

When it comes to merchandising, few items sell better to NBA fans than
  • Wholesale Jerseys the league's excellent assortment of team jerseys. Long known for a commitment to greater jersey varieties than competing leagues like the NFL, NHL, or Major League Baseball, the NBA provides its fans with some of the most unique and on-trend jersey designs of any major sports league. In addition, NBA fans will find plenty of replica jerseys
  • Minnesota Vikings
  • , championship jersey styles, and plenty of other options for the whole family.

    For those fans who are searching for the perfect
  • Movie Football Jersey
  • apparel option, FansEdge.com has virtually every jersey currently available. Our commitment to a robust selection of jerseys means that even the pickiest NBA fans can find exactly what they need to watch the game at home, cheer the team on at the arena, and pass the time between games all season long.

    Replica and Retro: The Most Popular Jersey Options for Today's Fans

    For most fans, there is exactly one kind of jersey on the shopping list before each new
  • New England Patriots
  • : A replica jersey that sports not only the team's colors and official logos, but also the name and number of a fan's favorite player. For those who are sticking with this traditional option, we have jerseys and styles for every single one of the NBA's teams nationwide. In addition to replica home
  • New Orleans Saints
  • , we have a series of away jerseys and alternates that are sure to diversify an existing collection
  • New York Giants
  • and stand out in a crowd.

    For long-time fans of the game
  • New York Jets
  • or those who simply enjoy a team's retro logos and colors, we have retro jerseys from across the league. These jerseys swap today's ultra-modern logos for
  • NFL Iphone Case
  • the look and feel of jerseys made in the 1990s and earlier. With timeless logos and even some retro player names or numbers, these jerseys are as in-demand as they are collectible.

    Championship Jerseys are a Great Way to Commemorate the Post-Season

    Commemoration jerseys for recent
  • Oakland Raiders
  • appearances are a great purchase for fans of the NBA's best teams. These jerseys swap team colors and officially licensed logos for NBA Finals branding, championship information, and team-specific championship logos. These jerseys are a must-have item for fans of championship teams
  • Philadelphia Eagles
  • , since they're produced in limited quantities and they're almost always deemed a collectible item shortly after their numbers run out.

    For Young Fans, There is No Shortage of Options

    NBA teams know that the best way to create a strong base of fans is to start early
  • Pittsburgh Steelers
  • , and that's why all teams have committed to a series of baby and children's items that fit those new to the rules of the game. The NBA's baby options include baby-sized jerseys and "creepers," perfect for use at home during the big game. For kids, there are plenty of jersey options that are virtually identical to our adult-sized offerings
  • NFL Shop . Younger fans of the game will enjoy replica and retro jersey options, as well as a limited selection of away jerseys or alternate jerseys that they might find even more appealing.


    Friday, June 24, 2016, 4:25 AM

    Add comment








  • Related Content:

    How To Lose Weight- The Basics
    Weight Watchers Points System
    The Fat Smash Diet
    The Eat To Live Diet
    The Beck Diet Solution
    How To Get The Motivation To Lose Weight

     

    How To Be Successful Using PEERtrainer

    How To Burn Fat
    Online Weight Loss Support- How It Works
    Does Green Tea Help You Lose Weight?
    Tips On Using PEERtrainer
    Visit The PEERtrainer Community
    Diet and Fitness Resources

    Fitness

    Weight Watchers Meetings
    Learning To Inspire Others: You Already Are
    Writing Down Your Daily Workouts
    Spending Money On A Personal Trainer?
    How I Became A Marathon Runner

     

    Preventive Health

    How To Prevent Injuries During Your Workout
    Flu Season: Should You Take The Flu Shot?
    Are You Really Ready To Start PEERtrainer?
    Super Foods That Can Boost Your Energy
    Reversing Disease Through Nutrition

    New Diet and Fitness Articles:

    Weight Watchers Points Plus
    How To Adjust Your Body To Exercise
    New: Weight Watchers Momentum Program
    New: PEERtrainer Blog Archive
    Review Of The New Weight Watchers Momentum Program
     

    Weight Loss Motivation by Joshua Wayne:

    Why Simple Goal Setting Is Not Enough
    How To Delay Short Term Gratification
    How To Stay Motivated
    How To Exercise With A Busy Schedule

    Real World Nutrition and Fitness Questions

    Can Weight Lifting Help You Lose Weight?
    Are Protein Drinks Safe?
    Nutrition As Medicine?
     

    Everyday Weight Loss Tips

    How To Eat Healthy At A Party
    How To Eat Out And Still Lose Weight
    The Three Bite Rule
    Tips On How To Stop A Binge