CommunityBrowse groupsBlogEtiquetteInvite Your friendsSuccess Stories


elliptical vs running?

I've been trying to get back into working out, but each time I have gone to the gym I get so tired when I run. So I give up. I just realized what I was doing so I did the elliptical trainer instead. It was SO much easier. I got a long workout in, for the first time in a while. Now my question is, is the elliptical as good a workout as running is? Should I start to shift towards more running as I get in shape?

Sun. Aug 26, 9:58am

Add comment  
I agree the elliptical is easy! But it's a great work out. I run outside when I can and then the elliptical when I can't. I think it works different parts of your body and so it's helps you too. As long as you exercise then pat yourself on the back. I really enjoy my outside runs but get frustrated since of course I can't go as long. But I tell my self each little mile is better than nothing. I would love to hear what the runners out here think of the elliptical too.

Sunday, August 26, 2007, 10:19 AM

Add comment
Hi all,

I'm a new runner - doing my first 5K this year and am now training for a 10K. But I also use the bike and x-trainer 3 days a week too.

Sometimes I feel like running, and sometimes I don't and I tend to follow what my body tells me. I really think that the x-trainer is fab, and you definiately lose weight on it (try the random or hill modes for the bst workout). BUT, for my heart, running is definitely the best for me. I don't like running every day though so I tend to do one day run, one day x-train 6 days a week.

The key to it though, is do what you want, when you want! :^) Enjoy!

Sunday, August 26, 2007, 3:03 PM

Add comment
I think both can give you a great cardio workout. The 'danger' with the ellipitical is that it's very easy to make it EASY and not really challenge yourself. Running is so hard on the body, though, especially if you have some lbs to lose, which where you're doing yourself more of a favor by getting a good workout from the elliptical.

Don't forgert about resistance training - awesome workout and SO good for you!

Sunday, August 26, 2007, 3:11 PM

Add comment
Yeah - you can go for a long time on the elliptical without really doing much 'work' - make sure you have some resistance and intervals in there, and don't neglect your form (ie: don't sway from side to side) or you can stress your hips. Otherwise it's a great form of exercise and easy on the joints. definitely mix it up though.

Sunday, August 26, 2007, 5:25 PM

Add comment
do a search as this subject has been beaten to death here.

I'm opposed to ellipticals because they almost always put your body out of alignment, which is not a good way to exercise. Further more, it's less challenging than running, however the percieved rate (and not the actual rate) of exertion is invariably higher.

Run, jog, or walk quickly up inclines- all challenging. You don't need to run to sweat on a treadmill.

Sunday, August 26, 2007, 9:51 PM

Add comment
Ellipticals are not as tough on your joints. THe puonding from running can do lots of damange to the feet, knees, hips and even the back. another alternative is the ArcTrainer.

I do find it harder to run, but can't really say why. I wear a heart rate monitor and find that my heart rate gets up close to max with both running and ellitptical.

Sunday, August 26, 2007, 10:48 PM

Add comment
ellipticals aren't as safe as they are advertised. at high inclines, they are bad if not worse than running on your knees. it's not the same damage as the pounding running causes, but it is bad for the knees.
posture is also an issue. i'm on the shorter side and for me to comfortable use the handles i am slightly haunched over. but even for regular and tall people most people i see do it bent over.

Sunday, August 26, 2007, 10:54 PM

Add comment
At least when it comes to running, when you do it properly, your knee was designed to take the impact.

Going on an elliptical, where knees are often doing circular lateral motions and benig stressed in that position is SO not what knees were designed for. Personally, if I get on an elliptical, my knees are hurting within about 30 seconds from the pressure. But I can run for an hour with no knee pain.

Monday, August 27, 2007, 8:19 PM

Add comment
It's the opposite for me, butI do not do the ellipticalwith a severe incline.

I had an ACL tare a few years ago and when I came out of surgery my doctor suggested that I stop running but was OK with cardio equipment like ellipticals.

Monday, August 27, 2007, 10:48 PM

Add comment
I too have had surgery which requires me to stay in shape with low-impact forms of exercise. So the elliptical is one of my few choices for minimal impact exercise. Thus I do use the elliptical, but little incline (the machines I use allow for seperate incline and resistance) and am very concious of form - when you pay close attention to your body alignment and posture on the elliptical it's a heck of a lot harder!

I used to use the elliptical somewhat indifferently - figuring there wasn't much of a way to use it wrong. Boy was that a misconception that was! It can be a good workout, and it's a nice option for those of us with impact restrictions, but I see a lot of "bob-and-weave" elliptical use.

Tuesday, August 28, 2007, 12:27 PM

Add comment

Cyber's ArcTrainer is another low-impact option. It has some elliptical qualities along with some stepper characteristics. It gives a great workout. But like with everything, form is key.

Tuesday, August 28, 2007, 5:38 PM

Add comment

Has it really been three years since the
  • Wholesale Jerseys last World Baseball Classic? As we approach the second-ever World Baseball Classic odds, it is never too soon to start examining the power players. Keep in mind that after this WBC
  • NFL Shop , they will only come once every four nfl nike jerseys Here's the four major players in the upcoming 2009 WBC:

    United States +150 In baseball,cheap stitched nfl jerseys being an unknown team helps you because you become harder to scout and harder to prepare for
  • Arizona Cardinals
  • . Take a chance with the Cubans again. They take this tournament very seriously. As far as World Baseball Classics lines go, stitched nfl jerseyslook for the U.S. team to be a real underdog heading into the 2009 tournament
  • Atlanta Falcons
  • ?they might be worth a bet to win it all if the price is right.

    The Yankees underachieved in the 2006 World Baseball Classic and you can be assured that they will make some concerted effort to right the ship
  • Baltimore Ravens
  • . They boasted a fairly talented roster but neglected starting pitching, which was eventually the difference.

    Japan +800

    This is a pretty penny for a team that won the entire tournament in 2006. They are worth a flier here because keep in mind
  • Buffalo Bills
  • , for the most part, cheap nfl jerseysthe Japanese team is an unknown commodity. A lot of people are making assumptions and although the public perceives they are more flukey,cheap nfl jerseys than good, stitched nfl jerseysthe reality is that this is a stellar team. We're starting to get a taste with Ichiro
  • Carolina Panthers
  • , Daisuke Matsuzaka and Akinori Otsuka, but they are more than capable of winning it all again. Definitely a team to consider when you bet on the World Baseball Classic.

    Cuba +1000

    Speaking of great unknowns, it doesn't get much more mysterious than the Cuban team
  • CFL Jersey
  • . This team lost in the finals to Japan in 2006,cheap stitched nfl jerseys disappointing sportsbook diehards everywhere. The Cubans have a squad full of potential MLB All-Stars.stitched nfl jerseys cheap Last time around, the team was worried that a number of them might defect
  • Cleveland Browns
  • ,stitched nfl jerseys even though that that never turned out to be the case.

    Dominican Republic +175

    Go ahead, argue with a team that has Albert Pujols
  • Chicago Bears
  • , Alfonso Soriano, Jose Reyes and David Ortiz.stitched nfl jerseys cheap The sportsbooks certainly won't be debating it
  • Cincinnati Bengals
  • .cheap stitched nfl jerseys Interestingly enough, stitched nfl jerseys cheapthis team doesn't have as much starting pitching as you might think and if the US team brings some good starters, they should be able to beat this team. Bartolo Colon and Francisco Liriano led this starting rotation in 2006. They have some work to do but they can clearly outhit anyone.

    Friday, June 24, 2016, 3:01 AM

    Add comment
    2017 calendar
    blank calendar
    cool calendar
    yearly calendar

    awesome calendar

    our calendar

    new year calendar
    free calendar
    printable calendar
    real printable calendar

    timetable calendar
    schedule calendar
    calendar 2017

    calendar printable 2017
    blank calendar 2017
    2017 calendar
    2017 free calendar

    all calendar 2017
    useful calendar 2017

    schedule 2017 calendar

    2017 schedule calendar
    schedule calendar 2017
    blank calendar 2017-18
    calendar blog
    awesome site
    click here

    awesome site
    check this
    know this

    calendar go
    usa map
    america map
    map of usa
    map of usa
    Calendar 2018


    2017 calendar




    miss you

    year new

    Thursday, February 09, 2017, 4:50 AM

    Add comment

    botas de futbol

    zapatillas running

    pandora bracelet charms

    Pandora Official Website

    nike sb stefan janoski

    Canada Goose Outlet

    Nike Factory Store

    Jordan Schoenen

    ugg boots for women

    Air Jordan News

    Oakley Sunglasses Cheap

    official NHL jerseys

    hogan scontate

    sac coach soldes

    Pandora Store

    Bottes Ugg Femme Pas Cher

    ugg boots outlet online

    Ugg Outlet Online Store

    nike air

    scarpe hogan outlet

    nike air jordan pas cher

    Michael Kors

    Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher

    Kobe Shoes Nike

    Jordan Future

    Air Max 90

    Adidas Originals Superstar

    Nike Roshe Run Sale

    Vans Black Sneakers

    prada outlet

    23 is back

    ugg factory outlet

    uggs outlet

    Nike Air Max Cheap

    adidas schoenen

    Nike Zapatos

    Cheap Michael Kors

    Moncler Sale

    Yeezy Black

    Adidas Neo Discount Sale

    pandora outlet store

    chaussure basket homme



    Thursday, February 16, 2017, 10:44 PM

    Add comment

    fitflops sandals

    oakley canada

    celine handbags

    christian louboutin

    ray ban sunglasses

    air jordan

    nfl jerseys wholesale

    nike soccer shoes

    ray ban sunglasses

    ray ban wayfarer

    christian louboutin shoes

    true religion sale

    louis vuitton outlet

    cheap mlb jerseys

    michael kors uk

    louis vuitton handbags

    sac louis vuitton

    ralph lauren

    uggs on clearance

    oakley sunglasses

    louis vuitton handbags

    oakley vault

    ralph lauren polo

    boston celtics jerseys

    ray ban sunglasses

    michael kors handbags

    louis vuitton outlet

    jordan 8

    coach outlet

    michael kors handbags

    vikings jerseys

    giuseppe zanotti

    adidas neo

    cleveland cavaliers jerseys

    timberland boots

    canada goose outlet

    seahawks jerseys

    ralph lauren outlet

    adidas yeezy

    polo outlet


    Monday, April 10, 2017, 4:42 AM

    Add comment

    Related Content:

    How To Lose Weight- The Basics
    Weight Watchers Points System
    The Fat Smash Diet
    The Eat To Live Diet
    The Beck Diet Solution
    How To Get The Motivation To Lose Weight


    How To Be Successful Using PEERtrainer

    How To Burn Fat
    Online Weight Loss Support- How It Works
    Does Green Tea Help You Lose Weight?
    Tips On Using PEERtrainer
    Visit The PEERtrainer Community
    Diet and Fitness Resources


    Weight Watchers Meetings
    Learning To Inspire Others: You Already Are
    Writing Down Your Daily Workouts
    Spending Money On A Personal Trainer?
    How I Became A Marathon Runner


    Preventive Health

    How To Prevent Injuries During Your Workout
    Flu Season: Should You Take The Flu Shot?
    Are You Really Ready To Start PEERtrainer?
    Super Foods That Can Boost Your Energy
    Reversing Disease Through Nutrition

    New Diet and Fitness Articles:

    Weight Watchers Points Plus
    How To Adjust Your Body To Exercise
    New: Weight Watchers Momentum Program
    New: PEERtrainer Blog Archive
    Review Of The New Weight Watchers Momentum Program

    Weight Loss Motivation by Joshua Wayne:

    Why Simple Goal Setting Is Not Enough
    How To Delay Short Term Gratification
    How To Stay Motivated
    How To Exercise With A Busy Schedule

    Real World Nutrition and Fitness Questions

    Can Weight Lifting Help You Lose Weight?
    Are Protein Drinks Safe?
    Nutrition As Medicine?

    Everyday Weight Loss Tips

    How To Eat Healthy At A Party
    How To Eat Out And Still Lose Weight
    The Three Bite Rule
    Tips On How To Stop A Binge